Zur Seitennavigation oder mit Tastenkombination für den accesskey-Taste und Taste 1 
Zum Seiteninhalt oder mit Tastenkombination für den accesskey und Taste 2 
Hochschul-Informations-System eG
Startseite    Anmelden    WiSe 2020/21      Umschalten in deutsche Sprache / Switch to english language      Sitemap

Discovery, Pursuit & Justification in Science - Einzelansicht

Zurück
  • Funktionen:
Grunddaten
Veranstaltungsart Seminar Langtext
Veranstaltungsnummer 125889 Kurztext
Semester WiSe 2020/21 SWS 2
Erwartete Teilnehmer/-innen Max. Teilnehmer/-innen
Turnus Veranstaltungsanmeldung Keine Veranstaltungsbelegung im LSF
Credits
Termine Gruppe: iCalendar Export für Outlook
  Tag Zeit Turnus Dauer Raum Raum-
plan
Lehrperson Status Bemerkung fällt aus am Max. Teilnehmer/-innen
Einzeltermine anzeigen
iCalendar Export für Outlook
Do. 10:00 bis 12:00 woch          
Gruppe :
 
 


Zugeordnete Person
Zugeordnete Person Zuständigkeit
Kästner, Lena , JProf. Dr. phil.
Zuordnung zu Einrichtungen
Philosophie
Inhalt
Kommentar

”Scientific discovery” is often used to refer to both the process and the outcome of scientific inquiry. Scientific inquiry may focus, e.g., on hypotheses to be generated or tested, causes to be identified, or processes, things, and their features to be uncovered. Starting with logical empiricism, philosophers of science distinguished between a ”context of discovery” – where new ideas and hypotheses are generated – and a ”context of justification” – where those ideas and hypotheses are verified or falsified. This picture, however, seems to be both problematic and incomplete. Recent accounts of scientific inquiry question whether the contexts of discovery and justification can actually be sharply distinguished. Besides, they call attention to the fact that hypothesis generation and testing do not actually capture the full scope of scientific inquiry. Exploratory research, the development of new tools, and incidental findings, for instance, have played an important roles in many seminal scientific discoveries. Indeed, a lot of scientific work seems to go into development and refinement of theories, tools, and experimental protocols rather than straightforward hypothesis generation and testing. If this is correct, scientific inquiry in fact has a third aspect: pursuit, viz. the articulation and validation of theories and research tools. But how exactly should scientific pursuit be characterized? What is its precise relation to discovery and justification? And how does a closer look at pursuit help us get a better understanding of scientific inquiry and explanation? These are only some to the questions we shall discuss during this course. 

This course is highly-research oriented, background knowledge in philosophy of science is required. The course is run in close collaboration between Philipp Haueis (Bielefeld) and Lena Kästner (Saarbrücken). Students will be given the opportunity to engage with classic as well as contemporary literature on the topic. Additionally, there is a guest lecture by an international expert planned.

 

The course will be run online via zoom and MS Teams. Please join the course on moodle for further details.

 

Literature:

Reichenbach, H. (1938). Experience and Prediction. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Hanson, N.R. (1960). 1960, ”Is there a Logic of Scientific Discovery?”, Australasian Journal of Philosophy, 38: 91–106.

Hoyningen-Huene, P. (1987).  ”Context of Discovery and Context of Justification”, Studies in History and Philosophy of Science, 18: 501–15

Whitt, A.L. (1990). Theory Pursuit: between discovery and acceptance. PSA: Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association, 1, 467–483.  https://www.jstor.org/stable/192725

Steinle, F. and Schickore, J. (2006). Revisiting Discovery and Justification. Historical and philosophical perspectives on the context distinction. Berlin: Springer. 

Šešelja, D. and Straßer, G. (2014). Epistemic justification in the context of pursuit: a coherentist approach. Synthese. doi: 10.1007/s11229-014-0476-4


Strukturbaum
Die Veranstaltung wurde 26 mal im Vorlesungsverzeichnis WiSe 2020/21 gefunden:
Die Überschrift Seminare (S) aufklappen Seminare (S)  - - - 26